Mathematical Psychology

This project investigates mathematical psychology's historical and philosophical foundations to clarify its distinguishing characteristics and relationships to adjacent fields. Through gathering primary sources, histories, and interviews with researchers, author Prof. Colin Allen - University of Pittsburgh [1, 2, 3] and his students Osman Attah, Brendan Fleig-Goldstein, Mara McGuire, and Dzintra Ullis have identified three central questions:

What makes the use of mathematics in mathematical psychology reasonably effective, in contrast to other sciences like physics-inspired mathematical biology or symbolic cognitive science?
How does the mathematical approach in mathematical psychology differ from other branches of psychology, like psychophysics and psychometrics?
What is the appropriate relationship of mathematical psychology to cognitive science, given diverging perspectives on aligning with this field?

Preliminary findings emphasize data-driven modeling, skepticism of cognitive science alignments, and early reliance on computation. They will further probe the interplay with cognitive neuroscience and contrast rational-analysis approaches. By elucidating the motivating perspectives and objectives of different eras in mathematical psychology's development, they aim to understand its past and inform constructive dialogue on its philosophical foundations and future directions. This project intends to provide a conceptual roadmap for the field through integrated history and philosophy of science.

The Project: Integrating History and Philosophy of Mathematical Psychology

This project aims to integrate historical and philosophical perspectives to elucidate the foundations of mathematical psychology. As Norwood Hanson stated, history without philosophy is blind, while philosophy without history is empty. The goal is to find a middle ground between the contextual focus of history and the conceptual focus of philosophy.

The team acknowledges that all historical accounts are imperfect, but some can provide valuable insights. The history of mathematical psychology is difficult to tell without centering on the influential Stanford group. Tracing academic lineages and key events includes part of the picture, but more context is needed to fully understand the field's development.

The project draws on diverse sources, including research interviews, retrospective articles, formal histories, and online materials. More interviews and research will further flesh out the historical and philosophical foundations. While incomplete, the current analysis aims to identify important themes, contrasts, and questions that shaped mathematical psychology's evolution. Ultimately, the goal is an integrated historical and conceptual roadmap to inform contemporary perspectives on the field's identity and future directions.

The Rise of Mathematical Psychology

The history of efforts to mathematize psychology traces back to the quantitative imperative stemming from the Galilean scientific revolution. This imprinted the notion that proper science requires mathematics, leading to "physics envy" in other disciplines like psychology.

Many early psychologists argued psychology needed to become mathematical to be scientific. However, mathematizing psychology faced complications absent in the physical sciences. Objects in psychology were not readily present as quantifiable, provoking heated debates on whether psychometric and psychophysical measurements were meaningful.

Nonetheless, the desire to develop mathematical psychology persisted. Different approaches grappled with determining the appropriate role of mathematics in relation to psychological experiments and data. For example, Herbart favored starting with mathematics to ensure accuracy, while Fechner insisted experiments must come first to ground mathematics.

Tensions remain between data-driven versus theory-driven mathematization of psychology. Contemporary perspectives range from psychometric and psychophysical stances that foreground data to measurement-theoretical and computational approaches that emphasize formal models.

Elucidating how psychologists negotiated to apply mathematical methods to an apparently resistant subject matter helps reveal the evolving role and place of mathematics in psychology. This historical interplay shaped the emergence of mathematical psychology as a field.

The Distinctive Mathematical Approach of Mathematical Psychology

What sets mathematical psychology apart from other branches of psychology in its use of mathematics?

Several key aspects stand out:

Advocating quantitative methods broadly. Mathematical psychology emerged partly to push psychology to embrace quantitative modeling and mathematics beyond basic statistics.
Drawing from diverse mathematical tools. With greater training in mathematics, mathematical psychologists utilize more advanced and varied mathematical techniques like topology and differential geometry.
Linking models and experiments. Mathematical psychologists emphasize tightly connecting experimental design and statistical analysis, with experiments created to test specific models.
Favoring theoretical models. Mathematical psychology incorporates "pure" mathematical results and prefers analytic, hand-fitted models over data-driven computer models.
Seeking general, cumulative theory. Unlike just describing data, mathematical psychology aspires to abstract, general theory supported across experiments, cumulative progress in models, and mathematical insight into psychological mechanisms.

So while not unique to mathematical psychology, these key elements help characterize how its use of mathematics diverges from adjacent fields like psychophysics and psychometrics. Mathematical psychology carved out an identity embracing quantitative methods but also theoretical depth and broad generalization.

Situating Mathematical Psychology Relative to Cognitive Science

What is the appropriate perspective on mathematical psychology's relationship to cognitive psychology and cognitive science? While connected historically and conceptually, essential distinctions exist.

Mathematical psychology draws from diverse disciplines that are also influential in cognitive science, like computer science, psychology, linguistics, and neuroscience. However, mathematical psychology appears more skeptical of alignments with cognitive science.

For example, cognitive science prominently adopted the computer as a model of the human mind, while mathematical psychology focused more narrowly on computers as modeling tools.

Additionally, mathematical psychology seems to take a more critical stance towards purely simulation-based modeling in cognitive science, instead emphasizing iterative modeling tightly linked to experimentation.

Overall, mathematical psychology exhibits significant overlap with cognitive science but strongly asserts its distinct mathematical orientation and modeling perspectives. Elucidating this complex relationship remains an ongoing project, but preliminary analysis suggests mathematical psychology intentionally diverged from cognitive science in its formative development.

This establishes mathematical psychology's separate identity while retaining connections to adjacent disciplines at the intersection of mathematics, psychology, and computation.

Looking Ahead: Open Questions and Future Research

This historical and conceptual analysis of mathematical psychology's foundations has illuminated key themes, contrasts, and questions that shaped the field's development. Further research can build on these preliminary findings.

Additional work is needed to flesh out the fuller intellectual, social, and political context driving the evolution of mathematical psychology. Examining the influences and reactions of key figures will provide a richer picture.

Ongoing investigation can probe whether the identified tensions and contrasts represent historical artifacts or still animate contemporary debates. Do mathematical psychologists today grapple with similar questions on the role of mathematics and modeling?

Further analysis should also elucidate the nature of the purported bidirectional relationship between modeling and experimentation in mathematical psychology. As well, clarifying the diversity of perspectives on goals like generality, abstraction, and cumulative theory-building would be valuable.

Finally, this research aims to spur discussion on philosophical issues such as realism, pluralism, and progress in mathematical psychology models. Is the accuracy and truth value of models an important consideration or mainly beside the point? And where is the field headed - towards greater verisimilitude or an indefinite balancing of complexity and abstraction?

By spurring reflection on this conceptual foundation, this historical and integrative analysis hopes to provide a roadmap to inform constructive dialogue on mathematical psychology's identity and future trajectory.

The SDTEST^®

The SDTEST^® is a simple and fun tool to uncover our unique motivational values that use mathematical psychology of varying complexity.

The SDTEST^® helps us better understand ourselves and others on this lifelong path of self-discovery.

Here are reports of polls which SDTEST^® makes:

1) Kev ua ntawm cov tuam txhab hauv kev sib raug zoo rau cov neeg ua haujlwm hauv lub hli tas los (yog / tsis muaj)

2) Kev ua ntawm cov tuam txhab hauv kev sib raug zoo rau cov neeg ua haujlwm hauv lub hli dhau los (qhov tseeb hauv%)

3) Kev ntshai

4) Cov teeb meem loj tshaj plaws ntsib kuv lub teb chaws

5) Cov thawj coj zoo li cas siv tau cov thawj coj zoo thaum pawg muaj kev vam meej?

6) Google. Yam uas cuam tshuam pab pawg sib raug zoo

7) Lub ntsiab tseem ceeb ntawm cov neeg nrhiav haujlwm

8) Dab tsi ua rau tus thawj coj loj?

9) Dab tsi ua rau tib neeg ua tiav ntawm kev ua haujlwm?

10) Koj puas npaj kom tau txais kev them nyiaj tsawg dua los ua haujlwm remotely?

11) Puas muaj hnub nyoog?

12) Hnub nyoog hauv kev ua haujlwm

13) Hnub nyoog hauv lub neej

14) Ua rau muaj hnub nyoog

15) Vim li cas thiaj ua rau tib neeg muab (los ntawm Anna Vital)

16) Vam (#WVS)

17) Oxford Ntsuam Xyuas Kev Zoo Siab

18) Kev Ntsig Txog Lub Siab

19) Qhov twg yuav yog koj qhov kev lom zem tom ntej tshaj plaws?

20) Koj yuav ua li cas rau lub lim tiam no saib xyuas koj lub hlwb?

21) Kuv nyob xav txog kuv yav dhau los, tam sim no lossis yav tom ntej

22) Qib siab

23) Artificial txawj ntse thiab qhov kawg ntawm kev vam meej

24) Vim li cas cov neeg thiaj li ncua sij hawm?

25) Poj niam txiv neej sib txawv hauv tsev kev ntseeg tus kheej (IFD Allenbach)

26) Xing. Kev Soj Ntsuam

27) Patrick Lencioni's "tsib zaug ntawm ib pab neeg"

28) Empathy yog ...

29) Dab tsi yog qhov tseem ceeb rau nws cov kws tshaj lij hauv kev xaiv txoj haujlwm?

30) Vim li cas tib neeg tiv thaiv kev hloov (los ntawm siiobhán mchaale)

31) Koj yuav tswj hwm koj cov cwj pwm txawv li cas? (los ntawm Nawal litafa m.A.)

32) 21 Txuj Ci Uas Them Koj Mus Ib Txhis (los ntawm Yelemis Teo / 赵汉昇)

33) Kev ywj pheej yog ...

34) 12 Txoj kev los tsim kev ntseeg siab nrog lwm tus (los ntawm Justin Wright)

35) Cov yam ntxwv ntawm cov neeg ua haujlwm muaj txuj ci (los ntawm kev tswj hwm lub peev xwm

36) 10 yuam kom txhawb koj pab neeg

37) Algebra of Conscience (los ntawm Vladimir Lefebvre)

38) Peb Qhov Muaj Peev Xwm Ntawm Lub Neej Yav Tom Ntej (los ntawm Dr. Clare W. Graves)

Below you can read an abridged version of the results of our VUCA poll “Fears“. The full version of the results is available for free in the FAQ section after login or registration.

Kev ntshai

kab kos Correlation

VUCA

Tseem ceeb heev tus nqi ntawm cov correlation coefficient

Kev faib tawm ib txwm, los ntawm William Seas Gosset (Tub Ntxhais Kawm) r = 0.033

Tsis tas li cas faib tawm, los ntawm Spearman r = 0.0013

Qhia tsuas yog > r = 0.033

Kev faib	Tsis li cas	Tsis li cas	Tsis li cas	Zoo li ib txwm	Zoo li ib txwm	Zoo li ib txwm	Zoo li ib txwm	Zoo li ib txwm
Txhua nqe lus nug Txhua nqe lus nug Kuv qhov kev ntshai tshaj plaws yog
Kuv qhov kev ntshai tshaj plaws yog
Answer 1	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0569	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0313	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0161	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0906	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0297	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0118	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1544
Answer 2	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0225	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0002	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0450	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0644	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0442	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0128	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0940
Answer 3	-	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0030	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0116	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0411	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0465	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0466	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0786	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0200
Answer 4	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0440	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0354	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0189	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0150	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0299	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0204	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0986
Answer 5	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0309	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1278	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0137	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0728	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0011	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0195	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1757
Answer 6	-	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0001	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0086	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0623	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0085	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0193	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0829	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0319
Answer 7	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0127	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0385	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0683	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0246	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0468	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0640	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0519
Answer 8	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0700	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0853	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0322	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0146	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0344	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0132	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1370
Answer 9	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0670	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1680	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0087	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0692	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0132	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0518	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1822
Answer 10	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0784	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0758	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0199	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0245	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0342	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0133	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1308
Answer 11	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0586	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0528	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0091	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0074	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0198	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0318	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1198
Answer 12	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0392	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1042	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0353	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0357	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0249	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0297	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1526
Answer 13	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0646	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1052	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0444	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0266	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0416	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0176	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1605
Answer 14	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0714	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1026	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0002	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0090	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0012	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0086	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1174
Answer 15	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0558	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.1369	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0419	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0176	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0163	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0222	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.1183
Answer 16	-	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0592	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0275	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0384	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0402	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0652	Tsis muaj zog zoo 0.0283	Tsis muaj zog tsis zoo -0.0710

Export rau MS Excel

Cov haujlwm no yuav muaj nyob rau hauv koj tus kheej VUCA kev xaiv tsa

Ua li cas

You can not only just create your poll in the tariff «V.U.C.A poll designer» (with a unique link and your logo) but also you can earn money by selling its results in the tariff «Daim pam khw», as already the authors of polls.

If you participated in VUCA polls, you can see your results and compare them with the overall polls results, which are constantly growing, in your personal account after purchasing tariff «Kuv SDT»

[1] https://twitter.com/wileyprof

[2] https://colinallen.dnsalias.org

[3] https://philpeople.org/profiles/colin-allen

2023.10.13

Valerii Kosenko

Khoom Siv Khoom Saas Tsiaj Txoj Haujlwm SDTET®

Valerii tau tsim nyog raws li kev sib raug zoo-tus kws kho mob hlwb thaum xyoo 1993 thiab muaj txij xyoo thov nws kev paub hauv Project Tswj.
Valerii tau txais Master's degree thiab qhov project thiab Project Tus Thawj Coj tsim nyog rau hauv xyoo 2013. Thaum nws paub txog txoj haujlwm Geesellschaft E. V.) thiab muab kauv ntom.
Valerii tau siv ntau yam kev ntsuam xyuas muaj zog thiab siv nws txoj kev paub thiab kev paub los hloov qhov tam sim no version ntawm sdtest.
Valerii yog tus sau tshawb fawb txog qhov tsis paub tseeb ntawm V.U.c.a. Lub tswv yim siv cov kab mob muab kauv thiab cov lej lej hauv kev ua lej, ntau dua 20 cov chaw xaiv tsa thoob ntiaj teb.

Cov ncej no muaj 0 Lus

Teb rau

Rho tawm ib daim teb

Cia koj cov lus